On the issue of the multidirectional evolution of the lobbing phenomenon
https://doi.org/10.24290/1029-3736-2025-31-1-44-62
Abstract
Th is article continues series of publications by the author dedicated to the nature and functions of lobbying in the modern world. Th e author considers lobbying as a multifaceted phenomenon that has gone through a long process of evolution. Th e author suggests looking at lobbying in a historical perspective to show how its genesis was integrated into the logic of the development of the modern state and the market, simultaneously demonstrating why the dysfunctional side of lobbying was always a natural side-eff ect. In the article, the author proposes an innovative periodization of the evolution of lobbying, thus fi lling the gap in Russian political comparative studies in general and in the study of lobbying in particular. Th e author, relying on the logic of Arthur Bentley, shows that lobbying in various forms was inherent in polities and states at diff erent times. However, as the structure of states changed and became more complex, the role of lobbying changed as well. At the same time, the author demonstrates why lobbying remains a largely shadow phenomenon that requires close attention both from the point of view of its further institutionalization and the risks it poses to society and the state. In the conclusions of the article, the author emphasizes that in order to transform lobbying from an informal and illegitimate phenomenon in the public consciousness into a civilized process of interaction between the state and society, the priority should be given to developing a lobbying culture. It is necessary to develop a system of ethical standards for both business and the state, create a professional standard for lobbyists, and continue to improve anti-corruption legislation. But the most important thing is to shift the focus from lobbying based on private interests to lobbying that would refl ect public interests. Only in such way will it be possible to cleanse lobbying of the aura of constant scandals and dishonesty, instead turning it into a normal element of the political process
About the Author
P. S. KanevskyRussian Federation
Kanevsky Pavel S., Candidate of Political Sciences, Associate Professor, Department
of Political Science and Sociology of Political Processes, Faculty of Sociology
Leninsky Gory, 1-33, Moscow, 119234
References
1. Almond G., Paujell Dzh., Strom K., Dalton R. Sravnitel’naja politologija segodnja [Comparative Politics Today]. Mirovoj obzor. M., 2002 (in Russian).
2. Bentley A. Th e process of government: a study of social pressures. Chicago, 1908. Berry J. On the origins of public interest groups: a test of two theories // Polity. 1978. Vol. 10. N 3.
3. Bill’ o pravah. Gosudarstvennyj departament SShA [Bill of Rights. US Department of State]. URL: https://photos.state.gov/libraries/adana/30145/publications-other-lang/RUSSIAN.pdf (data obrashhenija: 07.11.2024) (in Russian).
4. Degtjarev A.A. O roli formal’nyh principov i neformal’nyh pravil v sovremennom GR-menedzhmente [On the Role of Formal Principles and Informal Rules in Modern GR Management] // Gosudarstvo, biznes, obshhestvo: sovremennye teorii i rossijskie realii / Pod red. L.E. Il’ichevoj. M., 2012 (in Russian).
5. Djurkgejm Je. Sociologija. Ee predmet, metod, prednaznachenie [Sociology. Its Subject, Method, Purpose]. M., 1995 (in Russian).
6. Federalist: Politicheskie jesse A. Gamil’tona, Dzh. Mjedisona i Dzh. Dzheja [Federalist: Political essays by A. Hamilton, J. Madison and J. Jay]. M., 1994 (in Russian).
7. Federal’nyj zakon ot 25 dekabrja 2008 g. N 273-FZ “O protivodejstvii korrupcii” (s izmenenijami i dopolnenijami) [Federal Law of December 25, 2008 N 273-FZ “On Combating Corruption” (with amendments and additions)] // Informacionnopravovoj portal GARANT.RU. URL: https://base.garant.ru/12164203/ (in Russian).
8. Grier P. Th e lobbyist through history: villainy and virtue // Christian Science Monitor. 28.09.2009. URL: http://features.csmonitor.com/politics/2009/09/28/thelobbyist-through-history-villainy-andvirtue/ (accessed: 07.11.2024).
9. Heywood A. Politics. L., 1997.
10. Kanevskij P.S. Genezis instituta lobbizma v Rossii: postsovetskij period i sovremennost’ [Genesis of the lobbying institute in Russia: the post-Soviet period and modernity] // Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Serija 18. Sociologija i politologija. 2021. N 4 (in Russian).
11. Kanevskij P.S. Genezis instituta lobbizma v Rossii: dorevoljucionnyj i sovetskij periody [Genesis of the Institute of Lobbying in Russia: Pre-Revolutionary and Soviet Periods] // Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Serija 18. Sociologija i politologija. 2022. N 1 (in Russian).
12. Kyle C. Open doors: pressure groups and lobbying // Th eater of State: Parliament and Political Culture in Early Stuart England. Redwood City. 2012. N 3. Ljubimov A.P. Istorija lobbizma v Rossii [History of lobbying in Russia]. M., 2005 (in Russian).
13. Malinovskij B. Funkcional’nyj analiz [Functional analysis] // Antologija issledovanij kul’tury. T. 1. SPb., 1997 (in Russian).
14. McGrath C. British lobbying in newspaper and parliamentary discourse, 1800– 1950 // Parliamentary History. 2018. Vol. 37. P. 2.
15. Nehaj D.A. Istoki formirovanija korporativnogo prava Zapadnoj Evropy [Origins of the formation of corporate law in Western Europe] // Obshhestvo i pravo. 2012. N 3 (in Russian).
16. Pavroz A.V. Gruppa interesov i lobbizm v politike [Interest group and lobbying in politics]. SPb., 2006 (in Russian).
17. Pobedonoscev K. Kurs grazhdanskogo prava [Civil law course]. M., 1880. Ch. 3 (in Russian).
18. Rothstein B. Th e quality of government: corruption, social trust, and inequality in international perspective. Chicago, 2011.
19. Shapkin I.N. Iz istorii lobbizma v Rossii: Predstavitel’skie organizacii rossijskogo kapitala vo vtoroj polovine XIX — nachale XX vekov [From the history of lobbying in Russia: Representative organizations of Russian capital in the second half of the XIX — early XX centuries]. M., 1999 (in Russian).
20. The emperor’s ear. Lobbying and networking at the Roman imperial court during the principate. GCLA — Ghent Centre for Late Antiquity. URL: https://research.flw.ugent.be/en/projects/emperor%E2%80%99s-ear-lobbying-and-networking-romanimperial-court-during-principate (accessed: 07.11.2024).
21. The Origins of “Lobbyist” // Merriam Webster. URL: https://www.merriamwebster.com/words-at-play/the-origins-of-lobbyist (accessed: 07.11.2024).
22. Thompson M.S. Corruption or confusion? Lobbying and Congressional Government in the Early Gilded Age // Congress & the Presidency. 1983. N 10 (2).
23. Tichenor D., Harris R. Th e development of interest group politics in America: beyond the conceits of modern times // Annual Review of Political Science. 2005. Vol. 8. Tolstyh P.A. GR. Praktikum po lobbizmu v Rossii [GR. Workshop on lobbying in Russia]. M., 2007 (in Russian).
24.
Review
For citations:
Kanevsky P.S. On the issue of the multidirectional evolution of the lobbing phenomenon. Moscow State University Bulletin. Series 18. Sociology and Political Science. 2025;31(1):44-62. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24290/1029-3736-2025-31-1-44-62