Preview

Moscow State University Bulletin. Series 18. Sociology and Political Science

Advanced search

THE FEDERAL LIST OF EXTREMIST MATERIALS AS A CULTURAL ARTEFACT “FAN-FICTION”

https://doi.org/10.24290/1029-3736-2017-23-1-193-207

Abstract

The article suggests the analysis of problem of counteraction to distribution of extremist materials. According to the author, a strictly legal interpretation of the Federal list of extremist materials ignores the problem of the nature of extremist materials and the question of the applicability of this concept. As a result extremist materials can be understood as phantom, determined by fight the power with its political opponents. Overcoming this negative interpretation is possible through the interpretation of extremist materials in the context of the practices of the prohibition of texts that took place in society at different historical stages. Qualitative difference of extremist materials from other forms of censorship sets a postmodern culture in which there is a transformation of the concept of the author of the text up until his disappearance. This is the epitome of cultures fan-fiction – free community of persons who in their literary works – fanfiction – develop, modify or refine some of the original idea, embodied in a book, film, computer game. The author offers the interpretation of extremist materials as of fanfics object, where the list of extremist materials sets the boundaries of the field of extremist ideas, acting as a marker of the space limitation of the creative generation of information in the world of mass culture.

About the Author

E. V. Salnikov
Orel Law Institute of the Ministerium of Interior name V.V. Lukyanov
Russian Federation
Salnikov Evgeniy Vyacheslavovich, PhD (philosophy), associate professor, chief of chair of social-philosophical disciplines


References

1. Antipina Ju.V. Zhanrovye osobennosti fanatskoj prozy (na primere fanfikshena po tvorchestvu brat’ev Strugackih) [Genre peculiarities of fan prose (on the example of fanficcing on the works of the Strugatsky brothers)] // Vestnik Che-ljabinskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Bulletin Chelyabinsk state University]. 2011. N 13 (in Russian).

2. Berdnikov D.V. Psihologicheskoe issledovanie jekstremistskogo teksta: teo-reticheskie aspekty [Psychological study of extremist texts: theoretical aspects] // Teorija i praktika sudebnoj jekspertizy [Theory and practice of forensic examination]. 2014. N 4 (36) (in Russian).

3. Bogoljubov S.A. Nuzhen li zakon o protivodejstvii politicheskomu jeks-tremizmu? [Do we need the law on counteraction political extremism?] // Ad-vokat [The lawyer]. 2001. N 11 (in Russian).

4. Chernjak M.A. Kategorija “avtora” v massovoj literature [Category “author” in mass literature] // Fenomen massovoj literatury XX veka [The phenomenon of mass literature of the twentieth century]. SPb., 2005 (in Russian).

5. Chetina E.M., Kljujkova E.A. Fandomy i fanfiki: kreativnye praktiki na virtual’nyh platformah [Fandom and fanfiction: creative practice in virtual platforms] // Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Rossijskaja i zarubezhnaja filologija [Perm University Herald. Russian and foreign Philology]. 2015. N 3 (31) (in Russian).

6. Denisova A.I. Fanfikshn, kak subkul’tura i fenomen massovoj literatury // Analitika kul’turologii. 2012. N 24 (in Russian).

7. Efimova N.I. Verbal’noe tvorchestvo i cennosti fandoma “potter”: ot fanfikshn k demotivatoru [Verbal creativity and values of fandom “Potter” from fanfics to the demotivators] // Jazyki. Kul’tury. Jetnosy. Formirovanie jazykovoj kartiny mira: filologicheskij i metodicheskij aspekty [Languages. Culture. Ethnic groups. The formation of the language picture of the world: philological and methodological aspects]. 2015. T. 1. N 1 (in Russian).

8. Fanfics as a subculture and the phenomenon of mass literature // Analytics of Cultural Science. 2012. N 24.

9. Fishman L.G. Ob jekstremistskoj literature [On extremist literature] // Nauchnyj ezhegodnik Instituta filosofii i prava Ural’skogo otdelenija RAN [Scientific Yearbook of the Institute of philosophy and law, Ural branch of RAS]. 2008. Vyp. 8 (in Russian).

10. Foucault M. Chto takoe avtor [What is an author]. URL: http://royallib. com/read/fuko_mishel/chto_takoe_avtor.html#0 (data obrashhenija: 30.10.2015) (in Russian).

11. Kallistratidis E.V. Leksicheskie innovacii s obshhim znacheniem “tekst” v rechevyh praktikah russkojazychnoj internet-subkul’tury fan fiction [Lexical innovations shared value of “text” in speech practices of Russian Internet subculture fan of fiction] // Filologicheskie nauki. Voprosy teorii i praktiki [Philological Sciences. The theory and practice]. 2013. N 10 (28) (in Russian).

12. Kirillova N.B. Koncept postmoderna kak javlenie kul’turnogo polifonizma [The Concept of postmodernism as a cultural phenomenon polyfoniska] // Pri-volzhskij nauchnyj vestnik [Privolzhsky scientific journal]. 2013. N 11 (27) (in Russian).

13. Korobko M.A. Kanon i fanon: sootnoshenie avtorskoj i kollektivnoj kartin mira v hudozhestvennom proizvedenii [Canon and Fanon: the ratio of copyright and collective worldviews in a work of art] // Jazyki. Kul’tury. Jetnosy. Formiro-vanie jazykovoj kartiny mira: filologicheskij i metodicheskij aspekty [Languages. Culture. Ethnic groups. The formation of the language picture of the world: philological and methodological aspects]. 2015. T. 1. N 1 (in Russian).

14. Kroz M.V., Ratinova N.A. Psiholingvisticheskaja jekspertiza smyslovoj naprav-lennosti jekstremistskih materialov [Psycholinguistic examination of the semantic focus of extremist materials] // Vestnik Akademii General’noj prokuratury Ros-sijskoj Federacii [The Bulletin of Academy of Prosecutor General of the Russian Federation]. 2007. N 2 (in Russian).

15. Lapunin M.M., Gordeev N.S. Protivodejstvie rasprostraneniju jekstremistskih materialov religioznogo soderzhanija: ugolovno-pravovye i kriminologicheskie aspekty [Countering the spread of extremist religious materials: criminal law and criminological aspects] // Pravo. Zakonodatel’stvo. Lichnost’ [The right. Legislation. Personality]. 2014. N 1 (18) (in Russian).

16. Larionova N.S. Uvlechenie fanfikshn kak forma jeskapizma sovremennoj molodjozhi [The hobby fanfics as a form of escapism of modern youth] // Sovre-mennye issledovanija social’nyh problem [Modern research of social problems]. 2011. T. 8. N 4 (in Russian).

17. Luneev V.V. Rossijskij jekstremizm: politika i realii [Russian extremism: politics and realities] // Kriminologicheskij zhurnal Bajkal’skogo gosudarstvennogo uni-versiteta jekonomiki i prava [The Criminological Magazine of the Baikal State University of Economics and law]. 2009. N 2 (in Russian).

18. Popova S.N. Gipertekstovye harakteristiki proizvedenij fanfikshn [Hypertext features works by fanfics] // Voprosy prikladnoj lingvistiki [Questions of applied linguistics]. 2009 (a). N 1 (in Russian).

19. Popova S.N. Lingvostilistika fanfikshn. Avtoref. diss. … kandidata filologi-cheskih nauk [Linguistic stylistics, fanfics. The dissertation on competition of a scientific degree of candidate of philological Sciences]. M., 2009 (b) (in Russian).

20. Prasolova K.A. Fanfikshn: literaturnyj fenomen konca XX – nachala XXI veka: Avtoref. diss. … kand. filol. nauk [And fanfics: literary phenomenon of the late XX – the beginning of the century the Kyiv art Insitute. Abstract of Diss. on competition of a academic step. candidate of philological Sciences]. Kalinin-grad, 2009 (in Russian).

21. Samutina N. Velikie chitatel’nicy: fanfikshn kak forma literaturnogo [The great female readers: fanfics as a form of literary experience] // Sociologiche-skoe obozrenie [Sociological review]. 2013. T. 12. N 3 (in Russian).

22. Savinov L.V., Dorozhinskaja E.A., Sigarev A.V. Jekspertiza spornyh informa-cionnyh (jekstremistskih) materialov: metodologicheskie i pravovye problem [Examination of the controversial information (extremist) materials: methodological and legal problems] // Kriminologicheskij zhurnal Bajkal’skogo gosu-darstvennogo universiteta jekonomiki i prava [The criminological magazine of the Baikal state University of Economics and law]. 2015. T. 9. N 2 (in Russian).

23. Solodovnikov M.V. Cenzura kak mehanizm social’nogo kontrolja: sociologi-cheskij analiz: Diss. … kand. social. nauk [Censorship as a mechanism of social control: a sociological analysis. Diss. on competition. academic step. the candidate of sociological Sciences]. M., 2011 (in Russian).

24. Sultanov A.R. Cenzurnoe proshloe i sovremennaja karatel’naja cenzura reli-gioznyh uchenij [Past modern Censorship and punitive censorship of religious teachings] // Advokat [The lawyer]. 2012. N 7 (in Russian).

25. Sultanov A.R. Priznanie jekstremistskim materialom smyslovogo perevoda Korana i voprosy dolzhnoj pravovoj procedury [Recognition of extremist material semantic translation of the Qur’an and the issues of due process of law] // Advokat [The lawyer]. 2013. N 11 (in Russian).

26. Timoshenko E.K. Fanfikshn soobshhestva poklonnikov jepopei o Garri Pottere kak diskurs [Fanfix community of fans of the epic Harry Potter as the discourse] // Stephanos. 2015. N 6 (14) (in Russian).

27. Timoshhuk A.S., Fil’kin K.N. Kazus suda nad Bhagavat-Gitoj Svami Prabhu-pady: genezis, analiz, reakcija obshhestvennosti i media [The court case over the Bhagavad Gita Swami Prabhupada: Genesis, analysis, reaction of the public and media] // Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Istorija [The Bulletin of Tomsk state University. History]. 2013. N 4 (24) (in Russian).

28. Zol’nikova Ju. Fanfik i original: sopostavitel’nyj analiz [Fanfic and original: a comparative analysis] // Sopostavitel’nye issledovanija [A comparative study]. M., 2016 (in Russian).


Review

For citations:


Salnikov E.V. THE FEDERAL LIST OF EXTREMIST MATERIALS AS A CULTURAL ARTEFACT “FAN-FICTION”. Moscow State University Bulletin. Series 18. Sociology and Political Science. 2017;23(1):193-207. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24290/1029-3736-2017-23-1-193-207

Views: 1502


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 1029-3736 (Print)
ISSN 2541-8769 (Online)