Development of lobbying in Russia: post-Soviet and contemporary periods
https://doi.org/10.24290/1029-3736-2022-28-1-278-300
Abstract
This work is a continuation of the series of articles dedicated to the genesis of lobbying in Russia. The article examines the specifics of the formation of the institution of lobbying from the moment of the collapse of the USSR to the present day. It is shown that the development of lobbying depended both on the transformations of the political system as well as on the changing norms of interaction between interest groups and the government. The development of lobbying over the past 30 years has passed through three stages: a chaotic period of structural transformations in 1991–1993, the stage of development of the democratic system and oligarchic economy in 1993–2003, the genesis of the vertical of power from 2003 to the present. Specifics of the institution of lobbying in Russia is determined by several key components. First, it is shaped by the interest groups system, which circles around large corporations and business associations. Second, lobbying is determined by the structure of power and decision making, with the President of the Russian Federation, the Administration of the President and the Government being major institutional stakeholders for lobbyists. Third, the development of lobbying depends on modes of interaction between interests groups and public officials which basically remains mostly in the shadows. A fundamental problem in the development of lobbying in Russia is that both the executive bodies and the parliament are closed, non-public power structures, access to which for external groups is generally not systematized. This leads to the elitist, oligarchic tendencies of lobbying means that only few privileged groups enjoy access to the decision-making system.
About the Author
P. S. KanevskiyRussian Federation
Associate Professor, Candidate of Political Science, Department
of Political Science and Sociology of Political Processes, Faculty of Sociology
Leninsky Gory 1-33, Moscow, Russian Federation, 119234
References
1. Basmanova E., Berezovskaya O., Pushkareva V., Telnova S. Lobbizm v Sovete Federacii [Lobbying in the Federation Council]. Barnaul, 2021 (in Russian).
2. Basmanova E., Berezovskaya O., Telnova S. Lobbizm v Gosudarstvennoj Dume Federal’nogo Sobraniya (sed’moj sozyv) [Lobbying in the State Duma of the Federal Assembly (seventh convocation)]. Barnaul, 2019 (in Russian).
3. Elgie R., Griggs S. French politics: debates and controversies. L., 2013.
4. Faktor straha rossijskih MSP [Xe fear factor of Russian SMEs] // Vedomosti. 2020.09.21. URL: https://www.vedomosti.ru/salesdepartment/2020/09/21/faktorstraha-rossiiskih-msp (in Russian).
5. Federal’nyj zakon “O nekommercheskih organizaciyah” ot 12.01.1996 N 7-FZ (poslednyaya redakciya) [Federal Law “On Non-Commercial Organizations” dated 12.01.1996 N 7-FZ (last edition)]. URL: http://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_8824/ (in Russian).
6. Feldman P.Ya. Nuzhen li v Rossii zakon o lobbizme? [Does Russia need a law on lobbying?] // Vlast’. 2014. N 2 (in Russian).
7. Kirillina V.N., Popov D.R. Problema institucionalizacii biznes ob’’edinenij v Rossii [Xe problem of institutionalization of business associations in Russia] // Biznes. Obshchestvo. Vlast’. 2020. N 2–3 (in Russian).
8. Lyubimov A.P. Istoriya lobbizma v Rossii [Xe history of lobbying in Russia]. M., 2005 (in Russian).
9. Malyshev M.A. Tripartizm v sisteme social’nogo partnerstva [Tripartism in the system of social partnership] // Sociologiya vlasti. 2008. N 1 (in Russian).
10. Musienko I.M. Zalogovye aukciony kak faktor stanovleniya rossijskoj oligarhii [Mortgage auctions as a factor in the formation of the Russian oligarchy] // Problemy sovremennoj ekonomiki. 2013. N 11 (in Russian).
11. Neshchadin A.A., Blohin A.A., Vereshchagin V.V., Grigor’ev O.V., Ionin L.G., Kashin V.K., Malyutin M.V., Kravchenko A.I. Lobbizm v Rossii: etapy bol’shogo puti (prodolzhenie) [Lobbying in Russia: the stages of a large path (continuation)] // Sociologicheskie issledovaniya. 1996. N 4 (in Russian).
12. Pavroz A.V. Tendencii, problemy i perspektivy lobbizma v Rossii [Trends, problems and prospects of lobbying in Russia] // Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Seriya 18. Sociologiya i politologiya. 2018. N 4 (in Russian).
13. Sergeev A.I. Svoeobrazie rossijskogo tripartizma [Xe speciScs of Russian tripartism] // Izvestiya Rossijskogo gosudarstvennogo pedagogicheskogo universiteta im. A.I. Gercena. 2009. N 99 (in Russian).
14. Shchekolov A. Ekologicheskij lobbizm v sovremennoj Rossii [Environmental lobbying in modern Russia] // Vlast’. 2010. N 9 (in Russian).
15. Tolstykh P.A. Milliardnye oboroty dumskogo lobbizma [Billions of turnovers of the Duma lobbying] // Polit.ru. 2005. 28 Apr. URL: https://m.polit.ru/article/2005/04/28/lobb/ (in Russian).
16. Tolstykh P.A. GR: polnoe rukovodstvo po razrabotke gosudarstvenno-upravlencheskih reshenij, teorii i praktike lobbirovaniya [GR: the complete guide to governance development, theory and practice of Lobbying]. M., 2019 (in Russian).
17. V Minyuste otmetili umen’shenie chisla nekommercheskih organizacij v RF za tri goda [Xe Ministry of Justice noted a decrease in the number of non-profit organizations in the Russian Federation in three years] // TASS. 2020.03.31. URL: https://tass.ru/obschestvo/8125469 (in Russian).
18. Yakovlev A.A., Govorun A.V. Biznes-associacii kak instrument vzaimodejstviya mezhdu pravitel’stvom i predprinimatelyami: rezul’taty empiricheskogo analiza [Business associations as a tool for interaction between government and entrepreneurs: the results of empirical analysis] // Zhurnal Novoj Ekonomicheskoj Associacii. 2011. N 9 (in Russian).
19. Zasedali rezhe, boleli chashche, vnosili bol’she, razreshali men’she [Meetings were held less oeen, ill more oeen, contributed more, allowed less] // Kommersant. 2021.07.03. URL: https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/4636646 (in Russian).
20. Zasedanie Komissii po voprosam strategii razvitiya TEK i ekologicheskoj bezopasnosti [Meeting of the Commission on the development strategy of the fuel and energy complex and environmental safety]. 10.07.2012. URL: http://kremlin.ru/events/president/news/15912 (in Russian).
Review
For citations:
Kanevskiy P.S. Development of lobbying in Russia: post-Soviet and contemporary periods. Moscow State University Bulletin. Series 18. Sociology and Political Science. 2022;28(1):278-300. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24290/1029-3736-2022-28-1-278-300