The phenomenon of the “Russian idea”: origins, components and spiritual meaning

The article is devoted to the historical uniqueness of the history of our country, the identity of its people, which is reflected in the concept of the “national idea”. The essence of this concept is the search for the spiritual meaning of the existence of the peoples of our country, the identification of the historical mission of Russian civilization, the meaning of the joint existence of its peoples under the leadership of the great Russian people. The “Russian idea” — the origins of which can be traced back to the religious and philosophical work created in Russia in the middle of the 11th century — “The Word on Law and Grace” by Metropolitan Hilarion — is not an issue of ideology or politics. It is primarily a spiritual and cultural problem expressing the originality and uniqueness of the Russian spiritual experience. The author analyzes in detail the genesis, meaning and differentiates between the concepts of the “Russian idea”, which was first introduced into scientific circulation by F.M. Dostoevsky, and the “idea of the nation”, which entered into verbal circulation thanks to N.Y. Danilevsky, according to whom the “idea of the nation” was the idea of unifying the people within the framework of a national state. The phenomenon of the “Russian idea” is based on the postulates that “Russia is a family of nations” under the auspices of the Russian people, who have proven their ability to organize a state and economic colonization, politically and economically uniting one sixth of the earth’s surface, having a special, spiritual and moral mission in world history.

The article examines current issues related to the formulation of the “Russian idea”, in which outstanding Russian social scientists N.M. Karamzin and A.S. Khomyakov played a significant role, as well as its development, an important contribution to which was made by representatives of Slavophilism. Thus, K.S. Aksakov conceptualized the concept of “Russian outlook” as “an independent outlook of the Russian people, to which the Russian people, like others, have every right”. Much attention is paid to the socio-philosophical substantiation of the “Russian idea” in the works of V.S. Solovyov, as well as other “Russian religious philosophers” — N.A. Berdyaev, E.N. Trubetskoy, S.L. Frank, V.V. Rozanov, L.P. Karsavin, N.O. Lossky and I.A. Ilyin. These thinkers generally denied the possibility of explaining social life on rational principles and criticized the desire of Western researchers to ignore its irrational aspects, comprehended social reality from the point of view of Christianity and, above all, Orthodoxy. At the same time, the main emphasis was placed on the priority of the spiritual side of social existence. The author notes that the religious and philosophical truth expressed by Russian thinkers through the “Russian idea” marks a turn of Russian society to its original national and historical origins, and this turn was repeated at the end of the first quarter of the 21st century. The Russian idea is a unique synthetic concept of the path of development of Russian civilization, defined by the Russian national character, the heart of the Russian person, formalized in culture, based on the concepts of conscience, justice, internal freedom of the individual, which allows us to conclude that the Russian worldview is based more on religious and moral than on economic, political or legal concepts. History has convincingly proven that the arbitrary transfer of liberal ideological constructions, alien to the national mentality, to Russian soil contradicts national traditions, contributes to the destabilization of social life, and, ultimately, contradicts the national and state interests of Russia.

1. Alekseev N.N. Russkij narod i gosudarstvo [Russian people and state]. M., 1998 (in Russian).

2. Berdyaev N.A. Filosofiya svobody [Philosophy of freedom]. M., 2004 (in Russian).

3. Florovskij G.V. Puti russkogo bogosloviya [Paths of Russian Theology]. Parizh, 1937 (in Russian).

4. Frank S.L. Ocherk metodologii obshchestvennyh nauk [Essay on the Methodology of Social Sciences]. M., 1922 (in Russian).

5. Frank S.L. Duhovnye osnovy obshchestva [Spiritual Foundations of Society]. M., 1992 (a) (in Russian).

6. Frank S.L. Religioznye osnovy obshchestvennosti [Religious Foundations of Public] // Put’: Organ russkoj religioznoj mysli. Kn. I (I–VI) M., 1992 (b) (in Russian).

7. Frank S.L. Smysl zhizni [The Meaning of Life]. M., 2004 (in Russian).

8. Gorelov A.A. F.M. Dostoevskij: russkaya ideya i russkij socialism [F.M. Dostoevsky: Russian idea and Russian socialism] // Znanie, ponimanie, umenie. 2017. N 1 (in Russian).

9. Gulyga A.V. Russkaya ideya kak postsovremennaya problema [Russian idea as a postmodern problem] // Russkaya ideya: Sbornik proizvedenij russkih myslitelej / Sost. E.A. Vasil’ev. M., 2004 (in Russian).

10. Homyakov A.S. O starom i novom [On the Old and the New] // Russkaya ideya: Sbornik proizvedenij russkih myslitelej / Sost. E.A. Vasil’ev. M., 2004 (in Russian).

11. Horuzhij S.S. Posle pereryva. Puti russkoj filosofii [After the break. Paths of Russian philosophy]. SPb., 1994 (in Russian).

12. Il’in I.A. O russkoj idee [About the Russian idea] // Il’in I.A. Sobr. soch.: V 10 t. M., 1993. T. 2. Kn. 1 (in Russian).

13. Il’in I.A. O russkoj idee [About the Russian idea] // Russkaya ideya: sbornik proizvedenij russkih myslitelej. M., 2004 (in Russian).

14. Karamzin N.M. Zapiska o drevnej i novoj Rossii v ee politicheskom i grazhdanskom otnosheniyah [Note on Ancient and Modern Russia in Its Political and Civil Relations] / Prim. Yu.S. Pivovarova. M., 1991 (in Russian).

15. Katkov M.N. Pesni russkogo naroda, izdannye I. Saharovym. Kritika [Songs of the Russian People Published by I. Sakharov. Criticism] // Otechestvennye zapiski. 1839. T. IV. Kn. VI (in Russian).

16. Katkov M.N. Zametki [Notes] // Sovremennaya letopis’. 1857. Yanv. Kn. I (in Russian).

17. Katkov M.N. Bez nazvaniya [Untitled] // Moskovskie vedomosti. 1861. 26.02. N 47 (in Russian).

18. Katkov M.N. K kakoj prinadlezhim my partii? [To which party do we belong?] // Russkij vestnik. 1862. Fevr. N 2 (in Russian).

19. Katkov M.N. Vred u nas kazennyh izdanij [The harm that state-owned publications do to us] // Katkov M.N. Sobranie peredovyh statej “Moskovskih vedomostej” (1863–1887). M., 1897 (a) (in Russian).

20. Katkov M.N. Svoboda i vlast’ [Freedom and Power] // Katkov M.N. Sobranie peredovyh statej “Moskovskih vedomostej” (1863–1887). M., 1897 (b) (in Russian).

21. Klement’ev B.S. Slavyanofil’stvo kak religioznaya i bogoslovskaya mysl’ Rossii: opyt osmysleniya [Slavophilism as Religious and Theological Thought in Russia: An Experience of Understanding] // Gumanitarnyj vestnik. 2019. N 5 (in Russian).

22. Kudrina Yu. Dostoevskij, russkaya reforma i russkaya ideya [Dostoevsky, Russian Reform, and Russian Idea]. URL: https://godliteratury.ru/articles/2021/01/22/dostoevskij-russkaia-reforma-i-russkaia-ideia (data obrashcheniya: 02.02.2025) (in Russian).

23. Mel’nikova V.A., Beshkareva I.Yu. Osobennosti russkoj dushi, mentaliteta i haraktera russkogo cheloveka [Features of the Russian soul, mentality and character of the Russian person] // Intellektual’nyj potencial XXI veka: stupeni poznaniya. 2013. N 18. S. 118–122 (in Russian).

24. Osipova N.G., Elishev S.O. Istoricheskaya Rossiya: territorii i perspektivy [Historical Russia: territories and prospects]. M., 2020 (in Russian).

25. Pobedonoscev K.P. Velikaya lozh’ nashego vremeni [The great lie of our time]. M., 1993 (in Russian).

26. Proekt “Nacional’naya ideologiya Rossii” [Project “National Ideology of Russia]. URL: https://pero-print.ru/catalog/proekt-nacionalnaya-ideologiya-rossii (data obrashcheniya: 11.05.2025) (in Russian).

27. Razvitie sociologii v Rossii (s momenta zarozhdeniya do konca HKH veka) [Development of Sociology in Russia (from its inception to the end of the twentieth century)] / Pod red. E.I. Kukushkinoj. Uch. posob. M., 2004 (in Russian).

28. Rossiya: vyzovy vremeni i puti reformirovaniya [Russia: Challenges of the Time and Ways of Reforming] / Red. G.V. Osipov, V.K. Levashov, V.V. Lokosov. M., 1998.

29. Solov’ev V.S. Russkaya ideya [Russian Idea] // Russkaya ideya: sbornik proizvedenij russkih myslitelej. M., 2004 (in Russian).

30. Stronin A.I. Istoriya obshchestvennosti [History of the Public]. SPb., 1885 (in Russian).

31. Struve N. Pravoslavie i kul’tura [Orthodoxy and Culture]. M., 1992 (in Russian).

32. Tihomirov L.A. Bor’ba veka [The Struggle of the Century]. M., 1895 (in Russian).

33. Tihomirov L.A. Lichnost’, obshchestvo, cerkov’ [Personality, Society, Church]. M., 1904.

34. Tihomirov L.A. Edinolichnaya vlast’ kak princip gosudarstvennogo stroeniya [Sole Power as a Principle of State Structure]. M., 1993.