Faith, liberty, destiny, and the shaping of early American identity

The discovery of America, which was in itself a fateful event in European history, coincided with the crucial transformations taking place in the religious sphere. The development of printing technology, the creation of national translations of the Bible, the rethinking of the established forms of religiosity — all these innovations contributed to the creation of a special religious and religio-political climate of the era. England, which became one of the most successful colonial powers, was at the same time a country experiencing these religious transformations in an especially profound manner. Having proclaimed its ecclesiastical independence from Rome earlier than many other countries, England became a space for an intensive search for a new religious identity and a melting pot of various proto-messianic concepts. In addition, the competition of these new religious doctrines, existing in the shadow of potential and actual state-sanctioned oppression of dissidents, has created a specific environment that makes the issue of political freedom especially relevant and pertinent to the context of Christianity. Having received additional development in America and combined with an increased spread of the anti-colonial nationalist message, all these ideological streams could give a start to one of the most remarkable aspects of early American socio-political thought and identity, within which liberalism, republicanism, providentialism, messianism, and Christian religiosity are woven into a single composition. The debate about the influence of this ideological complex on the development of American identity and statehood continues to this day, sometimes leading to conflicting assessments. However, it seems that this phenomenon is, in one way or another, a remarkable factor in American history, which, to some extent, remains a relevant topic of discussion for modern America.

1. Acheson R.J. Radical Puritans in England 1550–1660. L., 2014.

2. An anthology of social and political thought from David Hume to the present / Ed. by J.Z. Muller. Princeton, 1997.

3. Adamova N.E. Predstavlenija puritan ob “iskljuchitel’nosti” Anglii i ejo edinstve s Evropoj: religioznyj aspect [Puritans’ View on the “Exceptionalism” of England and Her Unity with Europe: a Religious Aspect] // Trudy kafedry istorii Novogo i novejshego vremeni (SPbGU). 2015. N 15.

4. Ayer A.J. Thomas Paine. Chicago, 1990.

5. Bercovitch S. The American Jeremiad. Madison, 2012.

6. Birchall J. England under the revolution and the house of Hanover, 1688 to 1820. L., 1876.

7. Charles II, 1661: an act for the well governing and regulating of corporations // The Statutes of the Realm: Printed by Command of His Majesty King George the Third, in Pursuance of an Address of the House of Commons of Great Britain. From Original Records and Authentic Manuscripts. Vol. 5. L., 1819.

8. Coffey J. Exodus and liberation: deliverance politics from John Calvin to Martin Luther King Jr. N.Y., 2014.

9. Elizabeth’s act of Uniformity (1559), 1 Elizabeth, Cap. 2 // Documents Illustrative of English Church History / Ed. by H. Gee, W.J. Hardy. N.Y., 1896.

10. DzheSerson T. Bill’ ob ustanovlenii religioznoj svobody [A Bill for Establishing Religious Freedom] // Amerikanskie prosvetiteli. Izbrannye proizvedenija. T. 2. M., 1969.

11. Fea J. Was America founded as a Christian nation? A historical introduction. Louisville, 2011.

12. Fennessy R.R. Burke, Paine, and the rights of man: a diberence of political opinion. The Hague, 1963.

13. Feodor Studit, prep. K torgovcu aromatami L’vu [To Leo the Perfume Trader] // Tvorenija. T. 2. SPb., 1908.

14. Fortson S. D. Colonial Presbyterianism: old faith in a new land. Eugene, 2007.

15. Grasso K.L., Bradley G.V., Hunt R.P. Catholicism, liberalism, and communitarianism: the Catholic intellectual tradition and the moral foundations of democracy. Lanham, 1995.

16. Hess A. Tocqueville and Beaumont: aristocratic liberalism in democratic times. Dublin, 2018.

17. Hopkins S. The Puritans, or the Church, court, and parliament of England, during the reigns of Edward VI and Queen Elizabeth. Vol. 3. N.Y., 1861.

18. Jayne A. Jeberson’s Declaration of independence: origins, philosophy, and theology. Lexington, 1998.

19. Kirk R. A revolution not made, but prevented // Edmund Burke: Appraisals and Applications / Ed. by D.E. Ritchie. New Brunswick, 2011.

20. Lokk Dzh. Poslanie o veroterpimosti [A Letter Concerning Toleration] // Lokk Dzh. Sochinenija. T. 3. M., 1988.

21. Lucci D. John Locke’s Christianity. N.Y., 2020.

22. Morison S.E. The conservative American revolution. Washington, 1976.

23. Neal D. The history of the Puritans, or Protestant nonconformists. Vol. 1. N.Y., 1843.

24. Parker J. The first charter and the Early Religious legislation of Massachusetts // Lectures Delivered in a Course Before the Lowell Institute, in Boston. Boston, 1869.

25. Pejn T. Zdravyj smysl [Common Sense] // Pejn T. Izbrannye sochinenija / Pod red. M.P. Baskina. M., 1959.

26. Shalev E. Rome reborn on Western shores: historical imagination and the creation of the American republic. Charlottesville, 2009.

27. Shannon T.J. Indians and colonists at the crossroads of empire: the Albany congress of 1754. N.Y., 2002.

28. Sollors W. Beyond ethnicity: consent and descent in American culture. N.Y., 1986.

29. The Oxford handbook of the American revolution / Ed. by E.G. Gray, J. Kamensky. N.Y., 2015.

30. The Founding Fathers and the debate over religion in revolutionary America: a history in documents / Ed. by M. Harris, Th. Kidd. N.Y., 2012.

31. Waldstreicher D. Companion to John Adams and John Quincy Adams. N.Y., 2013.

32. Wilson J.D., Ricketson W.F. [omas Paine. Boston, 1989.

33. Zakai A. Exile and Kingdom: history and apocalypse in the Puritan migration to America. Cambridge, 2002.