The urban crisis of the 19th — early 20th century in Russian urban sociological studies of the pre-revolutionary period
https://doi.org/10.24290/1029-3736-2025-31-4-135-149
Abstract
The article carries out a historical and sociological analysis of Russian urban sociological researches of the pre-revolutionary period proposing approaches to improving the quality of citizens’ life. The interest in the issues of urban environment improvement discussed by sociologists today arose at the turn of the 19th — 20th centuries as a reaction to the social problems faced by big cities of that time, including Russian cities, due to the social inequality which worsened as a result of rapid and uncontrolled urbanization. It is emphasized that a significant contribution to the sociological study of the social contradictions of urban life and the search for possible ways to eliminate them is made by Russian social thinkers sharing the idea that urbanization should not be spontaneous, but a controlled social process in the late 19th — early 20th centuries.
Sociological researches by Russian social scientists seeking solutions of the social problems peculiar to big cities, are grouped around two sociological conceptions - the garden city and municipal socialism. The article defines the theoretical origins of these conceptual constructions and carries out a comparative analysis of these conceptions, thanks to what the huge heuristic potential of scientific developments created within the framework of Russian urban sociology in the pre-revolutionary period is revealed.
The author demonstrates that the social problems of big cities, as well as the principles of their solution, analyzed by Russian social scientists at the turn of the 19th — 20th centuries, are highlighted by modern sociologists examining urban life. The article concludes that Russian urban sociological studies conducted in the Russian Empire are a valuable heritage for contemporary Russian and Western sociology and are an important theoretical and methodological basis for sociological researches of city and urbanization in the 21st century.
About the Author
D. K. Guguev
Lomonosov Moscow state University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Guguev Daniil K., Postgraduate student of Department of Modern sociology
Leninsky Gory 1-33, Moscow, 119234
References
1. Booth Ch. Life and labour of the people in London. 17 vols. L., 1902-1903.
2. Castells M. The informational city: economic restructuring and urban development. Oxford; Cambridge, 2002.
3. Ensh A.K. Goroda-sady (goroda budushhego) [Garden cities (cities of tomorrow)]. SPb., 1910 (in Russian).
4. Gejl Ja. Goroda dlja ljudej [Cities for people]. M., 2012 (in Russian).
5. Gouard Je. Goroda budushhego [Cities of tomorrow]. SPb., 1911 (in Russian).
6. Howard E. Garden cities of tomorrow. L., 1902.
7. Isaev A.A. Bol’shie goroda i ih vlijanie na obshhestvennuju zhizn’ [Big cities and their impact on social life]. Jaroslavl’, 1887 (in Russian).
8. Isaev A.A. O socializme nashih dnej [On the socialism of our days]. Stuttgart, 1902 (in Russian).
9. Kovalevskij G.P. Bol’shoj gorod i goroda-sady [Big city and garden cities]. Kiev, 1916 (in Russian).
10. Kropotkine P. La Conquête du Pain. P., 1892.
11. Kropotkin P. Fields, factories, and workshops. L., 1898.
12. Kropotkin P.A. Polja, fabriki i masterskie (zemledelie, promyshlennost’ i remesla) [Fields, factories and workshops (agriculture, industry and handicrafts)]. M., 1908 (in Russian).
13. Kropotkin P.A. Hleb i volja [Bread and freedom]. Peterburg; M., 1919 (in Russian).
14. Kurchinskij M.A. Municipal’nyj socializm i razvitie gorodskoj zhizni [Municipal socialism and the urban life development]. SPb., 1907 (in Russian).
15. Mizhuev P.G. Sady-goroda i zhilishhnyj vopros v Anglii [Garden cities and the housing issue in England]. Pg., 1916 (in Russian).
16. Osipova N.G. Zapadnaja sociologija v XX stoletii: kljuchevye figury, napravlenija i shkoly [Western sociology in the 20th century: key figures, trends and schools]. M., 2018 (in Russian).
17. Ozerov I.H. Bol’shie goroda, ih zadachi i sredstva upravlenija [Big cities, their tasks and management tools]. M., 1906 (in Russian).
18. Protopopov D.D. Goroda budushhego [Cities of tomorrow] // Gorodskoe delo [Urban affairs]. 1909. N 18 (in Russian).
19. Sassen S. The global city: New York, London, Tokyo. Princeton; Oxford, 2001.
20. Semenov-tjan-Shanskij V.P. Gorod i derevnja v Evropejskoj Rossii [City and village in European Russia]. SPb., 1910 (in Russian).
21. Spenser G. Osnovanija sociologii. V 2-h T. [The foundations of sociology. In 2 volumes]. SPb., 1877. T. 2 (in Russian).
22. Svjatlovskij V.V. Zhilishhnyj vopros s jekonomicheskoj tochki zrenija. Vyp. I. Zhilishhnyj vopros na Zapade (Obshhaja postanovka) [The housing issue from an economic point of view. Iss. I. The housing issue in the West (General statement)]. SPb., 1902 (in Russian).
23. Svjatlovskij V.V. Zhilishhnyj vopros s jekonomicheskoj tochki zrenija. Vypusk II. Gorod i gosudarstvo (Prilozhenija: programmy, ustavy, zakony i proch.) [The housing issue from an economic point of view. Iss. II. City and state (Appendices: programs, charters, laws, etc.)]. SPb., 1904 (in Russian).
24. Terborn J. Goroda vlasti. Gorod, nacija, narod, global’nost’ [Cities of power. City, nation, people, globality]. M., 2020 (in Russian).
25. Vandervel’de Je. Derevenskij othod i vozvrashhenie na lono prirody [Rural retreat and return to the bosom of nature]. Odessa, 1904 (in Russian).
26. Veber A. Rost gorodov v 19-m stoletii [The growth of cities in the 19th century]. SPb., 1903 (in Russian).
27. Velihov L.A. Osnovy gorodskogo hozjajstva [Fundamentals of urban economy]. M., 1996 (in Russian).
28. Vershinina I.A. Zapadnye koncepcii goroda i urbanizacii v sociologii vtoroj poloviny HH — nachala XXI veka. Diss. … d-ra sociol. Nauk [Western conceptions of city and urbanization in sociology of the second half of the 20th — early 21st century. Doctoral dissertation in sociology]. M., 2022 (in Russian).
29. Zagrjackov M.D. Social’naja dejatel’nost’ gorodskogo samoupravlenija na Zapade. Vypusk I. Problemy municipalizacii [Social activities of urban selfgovernment in the West. Iss. I. Problems of municipalization]. Kiev, 1906 (in Russian).
30. Zimmel’ G. Bol’shie goroda i duhovnaja zhizn’ [Big cities and spiritual life] // Logos. 2002. N 3–4 (in Russian).
Review
For citations:
Guguev D.K. The urban crisis of the 19th — early 20th century in Russian urban sociological studies of the pre-revolutionary period. Moscow State University Bulletin. Series 18. Sociology and Political Science. 2025;31(4):135-149. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24290/1029-3736-2025-31-4-135-149
Views:
24
Email this article 